Difference between revisions of "Week 13-14 Questions/Comments-327 11"
From McClurken Wiki
(→Caroline Kirkland, 1863, defends Northern women’s support of Northern men) |
(→Caroline Kirkland, 1863, defends Northern women’s support of Northern men) |
||
| Line 114: | Line 114: | ||
== Caroline Kirkland, 1863, defends Northern women’s support of Northern men == | == Caroline Kirkland, 1863, defends Northern women’s support of Northern men == | ||
| − | Caroline Kirkland’s entry was such a great example of North vs. South. I enjoyed the fact that she felt sympathy for the women of the South, and then in the next sentence berated them for not doing everything they could to stop not just their soldier husbands, but also their faith in God. I thought that Kirkland’s selection was notable because she was a woman and very outspoken about what she witnessed, justified or not. – Pam P. | + | Caroline Kirkland’s entry was such a great example of North vs. South. I enjoyed the fact that she felt sympathy for the women of the South, and then in the next sentence berated them for not doing everything they could to stop not just their soldier husbands, but also questioned their faith in God. I thought that Kirkland’s selection was notable because she was a woman and very outspoken about what she witnessed, justified or not. – Pam P. |
== Ella Gertrude Clanton Thomas, January 1865 == | == Ella Gertrude Clanton Thomas, January 1865 == | ||
Ella Thomas's writing on life as a Southern woman in 1865 brings to life how devastating and traumatic the war really was in the south. Her fury stems from the unjust insanity at the hands of the Union army that is ruining her life as she knows it. She appears to be at the end of her rope with war and death stating," I lose faith in humanity when I see such efforts to sink the nobler better part of man's nature in an effort to exterminate the white race at the South in order to elevate the Negro race to a position which I doubt their ability to fill - The time will come when Southern women will be avenged." This is a deep quote and I believe it sets the tone for how most Southern women felt during and long after the war. In the first place most Southerners honestly did not see their actions towards slavery as being wrong and then then they are punished for it by having everything taken from them and destroyed. This undoubtedly would be a confusing and infuriating time for anyone in the South who had their lives completely destroyed. Thomas's writing reveals an intimate example of the tole that the war took on the South and helps to remind that Southerners were more than just wicked slave holders. --Rachel T. | Ella Thomas's writing on life as a Southern woman in 1865 brings to life how devastating and traumatic the war really was in the south. Her fury stems from the unjust insanity at the hands of the Union army that is ruining her life as she knows it. She appears to be at the end of her rope with war and death stating," I lose faith in humanity when I see such efforts to sink the nobler better part of man's nature in an effort to exterminate the white race at the South in order to elevate the Negro race to a position which I doubt their ability to fill - The time will come when Southern women will be avenged." This is a deep quote and I believe it sets the tone for how most Southern women felt during and long after the war. In the first place most Southerners honestly did not see their actions towards slavery as being wrong and then then they are punished for it by having everything taken from them and destroyed. This undoubtedly would be a confusing and infuriating time for anyone in the South who had their lives completely destroyed. Thomas's writing reveals an intimate example of the tole that the war took on the South and helps to remind that Southerners were more than just wicked slave holders. --Rachel T. | ||
