Difference between revisions of "HIST 131--Week 14 Questions/Comments"

From McClurken Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 2: Line 2:
 
First off, I thought it was interesting to here Lincoln's view on slavery and the Union in his letter to Greeley. So many assume that he was fighting to end slavery the whole time, but really he was fighting for the Union, and if it ended slavery, let it. It was neat to see how his view of slavery transformed from 1862 to 1863 seeing that by 1863 he wanted to completely abolish slavery.- Taylor Warner
 
First off, I thought it was interesting to here Lincoln's view on slavery and the Union in his letter to Greeley. So many assume that he was fighting to end slavery the whole time, but really he was fighting for the Union, and if it ended slavery, let it. It was neat to see how his view of slavery transformed from 1862 to 1863 seeing that by 1863 he wanted to completely abolish slavery.- Taylor Warner
  
 +
In the Emancipation Proclamation, Lincoln lists all of the parts of the state that are exempt from the freeing of their slaves, because these parts are not considered rebels.  He makes it clear that the only places that are to free their slaves are the places of rebellion.  I do not see the point in this because if the states are rebelling why would they listen to the government in which they are rebelling from?  ~Renee Rosser
  
 
== Statement from an Anonymous Former Slave, New Orleans, 1863 ==
 
== Statement from an Anonymous Former Slave, New Orleans, 1863 ==
Line 32: Line 33:
  
 
Did these ads actually work?  They contain so little information and the odds of the people they are looking for will read them are not very good.  Was this just a last desperate plea or were these actually successful? -Jenna Shevlin
 
Did these ads actually work?  They contain so little information and the odds of the people they are looking for will read them are not very good.  Was this just a last desperate plea or were these actually successful? -Jenna Shevlin
 +
 +
I found it interesting that in the Advertisements from the Christian Recorder many of the people who are looking for a lost family member refer back to the last person that he or she belonged to.  The Recorder's articles go until 1870 and in these articles the former slaves are still referring to the people who had once owned them or their loved ones.  This shows that even many years after the end of the war freed slaves still had to identify with their former masters to be able to help identify themselves and their loved ones.  They were not able to escape the title of once being owned by another person. ~Renee Rosser
  
 
== Black Convention in Alabama, 1867 ==
 
== Black Convention in Alabama, 1867 ==

Revision as of 15:15, 24 April 2008