Difference between revisions of "HIST 131--Week 13 Questions/Comments"

From McClurken Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Lincoln, KS NE Act speech, 1854)
(Jefferson Davis and the Pro-Slavery view of the Constitution, Speech before US Senate, May 1860)
Line 20: Line 20:
  
 
In Jefferson Davis' "Speech before the U.S. Senate" he states three reasons why they claim protection of slavery.  His first is that "it is our right"...how is having slaves a right?  How does he get that from the Constitution?  Another one of his reasons says "because we have entered into a compact together, which deprives each State of the power of using all the means which it might employ for its own defense".  My question is defense from what?  What do they need to be defended from and what does this have to do with slavery? -Jenna Shevlin
 
In Jefferson Davis' "Speech before the U.S. Senate" he states three reasons why they claim protection of slavery.  His first is that "it is our right"...how is having slaves a right?  How does he get that from the Constitution?  Another one of his reasons says "because we have entered into a compact together, which deprives each State of the power of using all the means which it might employ for its own defense".  My question is defense from what?  What do they need to be defended from and what does this have to do with slavery? -Jenna Shevlin
 +
 +
Did Jefferson Davis' "Speech before the U.S. Senate" have a direct affect on him becoming the president of the Confederacy.  And also, I noticed that there are many "..." in the speech; why did they cut down the speech?  Were there other sections of the speech that did not talk of the proslavery arguement?  Basically I am asking, was this speech written specifically to argue that the Constitution is proslavery or were there many issues addressed? -Ally Campo
  
 
== Granville Blanks, letter to the Editor, 1852 ==
 
== Granville Blanks, letter to the Editor, 1852 ==

Revision as of 01:56, 17 April 2008