Difference between revisions of "HIST 131--Week 9 Questions/Comments"

From McClurken Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(TJ’s Private & Public Indian Policy as seen in a Letter to Gov. Wm. Henry Harrison, 1803 & a speech to Native Americans ambassadors in 1806)
(Cherokees Debate Removal, John Ross and Elias Boudinot, 1836-1837)
Line 52: Line 52:
  
 
This was really interesting to me because it shows on a larger scale the impact of American Indian policy. Removal alone was a big enough impact on the Cherokees but also to look a little closer we see how removal not only tore them from their home but tore them apart as a nation. We see two men here who have different views one advocating resisting removal as a way to save their culture and another advocating removal as the means to saving the people and culture. The depth of damage inflicted on Native Americans seems to only increase with closer examination.-Melissa Brokaw
 
This was really interesting to me because it shows on a larger scale the impact of American Indian policy. Removal alone was a big enough impact on the Cherokees but also to look a little closer we see how removal not only tore them from their home but tore them apart as a nation. We see two men here who have different views one advocating resisting removal as a way to save their culture and another advocating removal as the means to saving the people and culture. The depth of damage inflicted on Native Americans seems to only increase with closer examination.-Melissa Brokaw
 +
 +
I agree with Melissa in that this document showed the impact of the removal of the Indians on a larger scale that we have not yet been able to see. It seems a little ironic that people who want freedom are so quick to push the Native Americans off their land. - Courtney Newcomb
  
 
== Madison Hemings Recalls Life as Jefferson's Enslaved Son, 1873 ==
 
== Madison Hemings Recalls Life as Jefferson's Enslaved Son, 1873 ==

Revision as of 01:37, 21 March 2008