Difference between revisions of "Week 2 Questions/Comments"
From McClurken Wiki
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
I was also a bit baffled at Heckewelder's discription and thought it contrasted so some of the ideas that I interpreted from our lecture on Tuesday. I got from the lecture that women not only pulled their weight, but really did more than that. Granted the region really determined the labor of both genders, but I got that women worked a lot harder than Heckewelder was describing. Maybe I'm just being a "feminist"- but I do not think that Hechewelder was giving women enough credit- but who is surprised about that? -- Talya Halpern | I was also a bit baffled at Heckewelder's discription and thought it contrasted so some of the ideas that I interpreted from our lecture on Tuesday. I got from the lecture that women not only pulled their weight, but really did more than that. Granted the region really determined the labor of both genders, but I got that women worked a lot harder than Heckewelder was describing. Maybe I'm just being a "feminist"- but I do not think that Hechewelder was giving women enough credit- but who is surprised about that? -- Talya Halpern | ||
| − | >> I do not think that I am being dense when I say that I | + | >> I do not think that I am being dense when I say that I think that Heckewelder's comments were not all that far from the truth when I compare his writing to our class lecture and to the account from Jemison. He may have exaggerated some about just how difficult men's work was but from where I am sitting it does not seem that easy to hunt animals or fight a war. Heckewelder does seem to have an interesting account of the way a marriage works but I also wonder if by the time he is doing his observations that the society which he was studying had changed its ways seeing as how this account comes from 1819 not the late 1600s or mid 1700s. (Julie Castanien) |
In Woloch's book, having to do with marriage and treatment of their wives,(p.9-11), I found it intersting how he says that there are many persons who believe, from the labour that they see the Indian women perform, that they are in a manner treated as slaves. These labours, indeed, are hard, compared with the tasks that are imposed upon females in civilized society, but they are no more than their fair share of the hardships attendant on savage life. So they are not only voluntarily, but cheerfully submitted to the work. | In Woloch's book, having to do with marriage and treatment of their wives,(p.9-11), I found it intersting how he says that there are many persons who believe, from the labour that they see the Indian women perform, that they are in a manner treated as slaves. These labours, indeed, are hard, compared with the tasks that are imposed upon females in civilized society, but they are no more than their fair share of the hardships attendant on savage life. So they are not only voluntarily, but cheerfully submitted to the work. | ||
| Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
This brings to mind the anthropological term of ethnocentrism to me. As the term suggests, the Europeans looked at the world through their own cultural perspective, believing that they are superior. All other societies are therefore judged based on their own views/culture/lifestyle. --Alex K. | This brings to mind the anthropological term of ethnocentrism to me. As the term suggests, the Europeans looked at the world through their own cultural perspective, believing that they are superior. All other societies are therefore judged based on their own views/culture/lifestyle. --Alex K. | ||
| + | |||
| + | >> I think that it is not possible to look at other cultures without using your own as a point of comparison. Now we do the best we can to be unbiased but we still have certain tendencies to misunderstand others. (Julie Castanien) | ||
Though Native Americans were not nearly as interfering in the lives of European settlers as the settlers were to them I think it is safe to say that the Native Americans would have viewed the European way of life as erroneous and as something that needed to be corrected as well. In fact, with what we know of Native Americans sharing their ways of farming it is possible that Native Americans felt and acted in the same way, seeing Europeans as ignorant and behind the times, only we do not have any primary sources to back up their of the story. Anyway all I am trying to say is that the Europeans most likely were not the only ones looking down on another group of people. Just interesting to remember that we only have one side of the story. --Allison J. | Though Native Americans were not nearly as interfering in the lives of European settlers as the settlers were to them I think it is safe to say that the Native Americans would have viewed the European way of life as erroneous and as something that needed to be corrected as well. In fact, with what we know of Native Americans sharing their ways of farming it is possible that Native Americans felt and acted in the same way, seeing Europeans as ignorant and behind the times, only we do not have any primary sources to back up their of the story. Anyway all I am trying to say is that the Europeans most likely were not the only ones looking down on another group of people. Just interesting to remember that we only have one side of the story. --Allison J. | ||
