Difference between revisions of "Week 2 Questions/Comments-327 11"
From McClurken Wiki
(→Captive John Tanner in 1830) |
(→Overarching questions) |
||
| Line 24: | Line 24: | ||
In the introduction to "First Encounters" in Woloch's book, she mentions that "During the era of colonization, Europeans at home and abroad had an insatiable curiosity about the New World." Perhaps it is possible that the sources we do have on Native American women are exaggerated in order to appeal to this rabid public. For example, John Smith's third account in which Pocahontas saves him from being killed is much more interesting to readers than his first account describing diplomacy. Another example would be Mary Rowlandson, who completely demonized the Native Americans and disregards any act of kindness. She describes them as a "scourge" and as having "inhumane, and many times devilish cruelty to the English." These incredibly harsh words would surely pique the interest of the European public as well. -- Clare O. | In the introduction to "First Encounters" in Woloch's book, she mentions that "During the era of colonization, Europeans at home and abroad had an insatiable curiosity about the New World." Perhaps it is possible that the sources we do have on Native American women are exaggerated in order to appeal to this rabid public. For example, John Smith's third account in which Pocahontas saves him from being killed is much more interesting to readers than his first account describing diplomacy. Another example would be Mary Rowlandson, who completely demonized the Native Americans and disregards any act of kindness. She describes them as a "scourge" and as having "inhumane, and many times devilish cruelty to the English." These incredibly harsh words would surely pique the interest of the European public as well. -- Clare O. | ||
| − | After Dr. McClurken’s lecture on Tuesday, the readings for this week were much easier to understand and conceptualize. I think it is interesting that there is no first-hand evidence of written records by Native American women or Native Americans in general. I also thought it was interesting that in the Woloch text, European settlement in the Indian societies negatively affected Native American women’s roles during the time period. The documents in this piece of literature were very insightful because they showed how the Native Americans were viewed by different people such as Roger Williams (a separatist minister), and Mary Jemison, who had a favorable view of the Native Americans who were keeping her held captive. --Catherine K. | + | After Dr. McClurken’s lecture on Tuesday, the readings for this week were much easier to understand and conceptualize. I think it is interesting that there is no first-hand evidence of written records by Native American women or Native Americans in general. I also thought it was interesting that in the Woloch text, European settlement in the Indian societies negatively affected Native American women’s roles during the time period. The documents in this piece of literature were very insightful because they showed how the Native Americans were viewed by different people such as Roger Williams (a separatist minister), and Mary Jemison, who had a favorable view of the Native Americans who were keeping her held captive. --Catherine K. |
| + | I find it mind boggling to see the observations of the Native American women from the colonists and Europeans and then see their interpretations as to why certain acts and traditions took place. For instance, from the Woloch reading, one of the colonists was curious as to why God took out the punishment of child bearing from the Native American women, even though he gave it to Eve. It almost makes me wonder how we would act if we were to ever go to a village in South America or a community in Africa. Would we be quick to judge and question their way of living? I honestly did not like how the European colonist tried to force their ideas on others. For instance, one colonist told the Native American man, that he had control of the final say and over his wife. This was not the dynamic and norm in that particular Native American community. --Aqsa Z. | ||
== Mary Rowlandson’s account (1681) and Mary Jemison’s account (1824) == | == Mary Rowlandson’s account (1681) and Mary Jemison’s account (1824) == | ||
