Difference between revisions of "HIST 131--Week 3 Questions/Comments"
From McClurken Wiki
(→Roger Williams) |
(→John Dane's Memoir) |
||
| Line 109: | Line 109: | ||
In John Dane's Memoir, I thought it was interesting that when John's parents discouraged him from going to the colonies, he took out the bible and decided that whatever page he randomly opened to would decide his fate. When the passage he read seemed to be telling him to go to the colonies, his parents all of the sudden we're encouraging him to leave right away. The bible seems to have totally control of the puritans, and yet they seem to twist its context because the passage John reads definitely does not clearly state for him to go to America, in fact it doesn't even seem close. --Helen Dinndorf | In John Dane's Memoir, I thought it was interesting that when John's parents discouraged him from going to the colonies, he took out the bible and decided that whatever page he randomly opened to would decide his fate. When the passage he read seemed to be telling him to go to the colonies, his parents all of the sudden we're encouraging him to leave right away. The bible seems to have totally control of the puritans, and yet they seem to twist its context because the passage John reads definitely does not clearly state for him to go to America, in fact it doesn't even seem close. --Helen Dinndorf | ||
| + | |||
| + | I question the childhood of John Dane and how it shaped his maturity. Why is it so that he can grow up in a strict Puritan community but yet have this desire to disobey his parents? Basically, I'm questioning whether his disobedience was determined by nature or nurture. It seems unlikely that he has a desire to go against the teachings of his religion when that is the foundation of his life. Did he just assume that he was inherently evil anyways so it didn't matter whether he was obedient to authority? -Ally Campo | ||
== Testimony against Bridget Bishop == | == Testimony against Bridget Bishop == | ||
