Difference between revisions of "Week 7 Questions/Comments"

From McClurken Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Deprecated: Optional parameter $attribs declared before required parameter $contents is implicitly treated as a required parameter in /home/umwhisto/public_html/mcclurken/wiki/includes/Xml.php on line 131
Line 10: Line 10:
  
 
I think Martha uses the name Mr. Ballard, who I am sure is her husband, out of respect and love for her husband as the provider and business man that he is.  I know when I was young it was not uncommon for couple who were elderly at that time to refer to themselves as Mr. Smith and Mrs. Smith.  Also couples who were business people tended to call each other by their formal names.  I am a big fan of the old T.V. series The Walton’s.  The Godseys were characters in the show that called each other Mr. Godsey and Mrs. Godsey.  They didn’t often use their first name when they where addressing each other. ---Cheryl
 
I think Martha uses the name Mr. Ballard, who I am sure is her husband, out of respect and love for her husband as the provider and business man that he is.  I know when I was young it was not uncommon for couple who were elderly at that time to refer to themselves as Mr. Smith and Mrs. Smith.  Also couples who were business people tended to call each other by their formal names.  I am a big fan of the old T.V. series The Walton’s.  The Godseys were characters in the show that called each other Mr. Godsey and Mrs. Godsey.  They didn’t often use their first name when they where addressing each other. ---Cheryl
 +
 +
I agree somewhat with Cheryl on why Martha refers to her husband as Mr. Ballard, but maybe this use of full names could give us some idea of why she kept the diary. It was obviously not solely for personal pleasure. Maybe she was keeping it so that later on others could understand it if necessary and she wanted to be clear about who she was referring to. She often references how much she paid for certain services or how much she was paid so I can't help but wonder what exactly this diary was kept for. For her own personal recollection? As some sort of family banking account? As proof of particular jobs and payments? -- Allison J
  
 
While reading over Martha's diary online, I was surprised to read the section about Martha's son and eventual daughter-in-law.  The couple had a child out of wedlock but the courts were less concerned with their immoral behavior but rather identifying the father so that the community would not be responsible for supporting the mother and child.  Is this evidence of the ongoing shift from a religious to a secular society ? --E. Hufford
 
While reading over Martha's diary online, I was surprised to read the section about Martha's son and eventual daughter-in-law.  The couple had a child out of wedlock but the courts were less concerned with their immoral behavior but rather identifying the father so that the community would not be responsible for supporting the mother and child.  Is this evidence of the ongoing shift from a religious to a secular society ? --E. Hufford
 +
 +
Religion still seems to be a very large factor in her life since she notes who in her family went to church on Sunday and she usually gives a clear reason if she doesn't go. She also talks about town meetings during which they decide to hire on preachers, etc. Possibly this concern over the father of the illegitimate child really is just a concern about money. At this time there would obviously be no government programs for single mothers or illegitimate children so something had to be done. Maybe this situation just shows that premarital sex did happen and it happened frequently enough that the community knew that it was important to take action before they were saddled with a child to care for. -- Allison J 
  
 
When reading Martha's diary dated the 9th of July 1806, I was appalled when reading of the Purrinton murders.  I was shocked in the sense that one does not usually attribute such horrific behavior to that time.  Many people today blame suicide-homicides on the society in which we live.  I found it intersting and horrifying that such atrocities did happen even two hundred years ago.--E. Hufford
 
When reading Martha's diary dated the 9th of July 1806, I was appalled when reading of the Purrinton murders.  I was shocked in the sense that one does not usually attribute such horrific behavior to that time.  Many people today blame suicide-homicides on the society in which we live.  I found it intersting and horrifying that such atrocities did happen even two hundred years ago.--E. Hufford

Revision as of 00:10, 11 October 2007