Difference between revisions of "329--Week 13 Questions/Comments"

From McClurken Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(6 Overall)
(6 Overall)
Line 34: Line 34:
  
 
I don't really care for this.  It wasn't very entertaining for me and it's not something I would ever watch again.  I didn't have any problems with the film jumping around, but I kept trying to figure out when he'd actually gone away, and therefore how old he was and how long he'd been gone.  We see kid Ron watching JFK's speech in 1961, then Ron is a senior in high school, then we are in Vietnam in October 1967.  Only after a parade when a speaker says Ron was born in '46 do things come together.  I was preoccupied with this on multiple occasions. -Whitney Holcomb
 
I don't really care for this.  It wasn't very entertaining for me and it's not something I would ever watch again.  I didn't have any problems with the film jumping around, but I kept trying to figure out when he'd actually gone away, and therefore how old he was and how long he'd been gone.  We see kid Ron watching JFK's speech in 1961, then Ron is a senior in high school, then we are in Vietnam in October 1967.  Only after a parade when a speaker says Ron was born in '46 do things come together.  I was preoccupied with this on multiple occasions. -Whitney Holcomb
 +
 +
Tom Cruise pre-Vietnam/during the war > Tom Cruise in the hospital to the end.  And, I know that's how the style was in the 1970s, but I couldn't handle it.  Everything just seemed to be too over-the-top almost and very very dramatic.  And I think abbreviating Kovic's life so much to fit it all in in 2 1/2 hours hurt the movie a great deal.  As the others said, it was so fragmented and scattered that I had a hard time keeping up with how old Ron was supposed to be, etc.  -Kelly Wuyscik

Revision as of 03:53, 19 November 2008