Difference between revisions of "328--Week 11 Questions/Comments"

From McClurken Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Rachel Carson Answers her Critics - 1963)
(Joanna Rubin, "An Unplanned Pregnancy" 1950s)
Line 28: Line 28:
  
 
This article made me sad as well because she had no one to turn to other than the guy that got her pregnant, however I thought it was interesting that they went to some random place in Puerto Rico with a doctor named Pardo.  Even though the boyfriend found out about this place through a friend it was no wonder she thought she might end up at some little dark room clinic that really wasn't lagit. She took a huge chance on flying out to this place that she really new nothing about.  I would have been scared out of my mind too.  There were places in the US that did these illegal abortions so I wonder if many other women went out of the US for abortions?--Michelle M.
 
This article made me sad as well because she had no one to turn to other than the guy that got her pregnant, however I thought it was interesting that they went to some random place in Puerto Rico with a doctor named Pardo.  Even though the boyfriend found out about this place through a friend it was no wonder she thought she might end up at some little dark room clinic that really wasn't lagit. She took a huge chance on flying out to this place that she really new nothing about.  I would have been scared out of my mind too.  There were places in the US that did these illegal abortions so I wonder if many other women went out of the US for abortions?--Michelle M.
 +
 +
Elizabeth and Michelle mentioned in their posts how alone Joanna Rubin was in her private ordeal.  Abortion is not just a physical ordeal.  Rubin says that she was okay with her decision in aborting a child, but this is the type of life event that she is less likely to share and will probably conceal.  At the time, abortion was illegal in the states and carried a stigma that would have probably alienated her and prevented her seeking emotional support from professionals and other women. Abortion doesn't just take a fetus away, it creates a void and replaces it with guilt and shame.--LisaM
  
 
I thought it was interesting to read Joanna Rubin's account of her unplanned pregnancy. My question is if JOanna knew the risks of sleeping with her boyfriend and she didn't see a future with him then why take those huge risks sleeping with him? It's not like she was uneducated as far as the risks and unsafety of abortions. It is a type of rebellion for women? -- Rose Ferguson
 
I thought it was interesting to read Joanna Rubin's account of her unplanned pregnancy. My question is if JOanna knew the risks of sleeping with her boyfriend and she didn't see a future with him then why take those huge risks sleeping with him? It's not like she was uneducated as far as the risks and unsafety of abortions. It is a type of rebellion for women? -- Rose Ferguson

Revision as of 01:34, 3 April 2008