Difference between revisions of "HIST 131--Week 10 Questions/Comments"

From McClurken Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(David Crockett Hunts Bear, 1834)
(Henry Bellows, on the influence of “Trading Spirit” on morality, 1845)
Line 11: Line 11:
 
Bellow makes the claim of Americans caught up in their pursuit of wealth, "We are not a happy people.  And it is true."  If this is an accurate statement of this country at the time, I was wondering if this, perhaps, was a confounding variable in the tensions between the North and South that were starting to build.  '''Can we argue that America was a country so overworked and stressed out that it needed its civil war to release those tensions, as well as provide a break from the everyday monotony of commodities exchange?'''   
 
Bellow makes the claim of Americans caught up in their pursuit of wealth, "We are not a happy people.  And it is true."  If this is an accurate statement of this country at the time, I was wondering if this, perhaps, was a confounding variable in the tensions between the North and South that were starting to build.  '''Can we argue that America was a country so overworked and stressed out that it needed its civil war to release those tensions, as well as provide a break from the everyday monotony of commodities exchange?'''   
 
-Adam Shlossman
 
-Adam Shlossman
 +
 +
Henry Bellows document he states in one part that "we call our country a happy country" but then later says "it is said that we are not a happy people"; isn't this a contradiction? Which one is it? It can't be both; either they are happy or they aren't. -Jenna Shevlin
  
 
== Walter Colton’s California Diary, 1849-1850 ==
 
== Walter Colton’s California Diary, 1849-1850 ==

Revision as of 12:37, 28 March 2008